Eighth meeting of the Interim Environmental Markets Board (15 April 2024)

Meeting outcomes

The eighth meeting of the Interim Environmental Markets Board (‘Board’) was held on 10th June 2024.

Amendments to the Market Rules

The Board agreed to a series of amendments to the Market Rules to clarify several matters in relation to the approval of Market Operator Fees and Market Settlement.

Market Operator Fees

The Board confirmed that a key principle of a high integrity environmental market is that the fees received by a Market Operator should be for services provided and not depend on the price(s) paid by Buyers for Credits or the payment(s) made to Suppliers for the delivery of Nature-based Projects (‘Fee Principle’). The Fee Principle is critical to ensure that that the Market Operator has no financial incentive to benefit from market prices.

The Market Rules were also amended to make it clear that the Board is not a price regulator, and that approval of the Market Operator’s fees is on the basis that they comply with the Fee Principle. The fees set by a Market Operator are ultimately a matter for its own commercial judgement.

Market Settlement

The Board approved amendments to the Market Rules to distinguish more clearly between the process of matching supplier offers and buyer bids and the allocation of the market surplus (‘Matching and Allocation’), from the confirmation by the Market Operator of the successful Supplier Offers and Buyer Bids (‘Market Settlement’).

The Board reaffirmed the previous amendments made to the Market Rules made in October 2023, confirming that contracts between the Market Operator and Buyers and Suppliers are formed automatically at Market Settlement.

Market Operator Audit

The Board was briefed on the appointment of the Soil Association to carry out the audit of the Market Operator’s compliance with the Market Rules. The auditor will join the Board at its September meeting to discuss the outcomes and recommendations from the audit.

UK Nature Market Dialogue

The Board endorsed the scope of a draft Market Governance Issues and Options Paper being prepared as part of the Nature Markets Dialogue in conjunction with the Broadway Initiative. The Board noted that the paper would be released for consultation in the Autumn.

BSI Draft Nature Markets Standard

The Board noted the submission that had been made to the development of the BSI Nature Markets Standard.

Catchment Market Operation

The Board approved the Catchment Opportunities Statement for the third Market Round of the Somerset Catchment Market.

Note: The Market Operator discontinued the third Market Round of the Somerset Catchment market after a major buyer advised that its registered bid was materially incorrect.

Next Meeting

The next meeting will be held on 8th September 2024.

Jill May, Chair.